> I bought two Seagate 'FreeAgent' external hard drives (500GB) at
> separate times. I mistakenly bought two different models - one has
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> -GECKO
Firewire comes in 1394a (400 megabits/sec) and 1394b (800 megabits/sec).
I suppose some might perceive that 1394b has more market penetration
on Macintosh systems, than on PCs, but I have seen the odd PC motherboard
that sported a 1394b port. You can also get add-in cards with 1394b.
SATA = 150MB/sec or 300MB/sec, and actual transfers would be platter limited
Firewire = 50MB/sec or 100MB/sec, and actual transfers will be less
USB2 = 60MB/sec theoretical, but practical rates are around 30MB/sec
for enclosures.
Some Firewire 800 benchmarks.
http://www.barefeats.com/note01.html
Various ports compared on Macs.
http://www.barefeats.com/hard70.html
1394a here, is able to do more than USB2.
http://www.tomshardware.com/de/Vergleich-Externe-Festplatten-eSATA,testberichte-
239800-11.html
Where 1394a sometimes falls down, is when drives are daisy chained. (I
used to own two 1394a enclosures and noticed this in testing. There is
a difference between putting a chain of two drives, versus connecting
each drive directly to the computer. The packets are "store and forward",
through the chip inside the drive #1 enclosure.)
computer ----- drive #1 ------ drive #2 (drive #2 is slower, like 20MB/sec)
computer ----- drive #1 (a better config)
----- drive #2
HTH,
Paul
>I bought two Seagate 'FreeAgent' external hard drives (500GB) at
>separate times. I mistakenly bought two different models - one has
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
>-GECKO
On paper 1394a doesn't seem as fast but in practice it is
often faster than USB2, on PCs as well as MACs.