Just wondering if anyone else has had similar problems with these.
I'm using Time Warner/Roadrunner in Southern California. Up until
mid-February I was using a 3COM shark-fin cable modem. It worked great
for about 2 years; I think I may have had to reset it once during that
period, but otherwise it stayed running 24/7, giving me 2-3 mbps down &
384 kbps up. I had nothing but good things to say about Time-Warner,
especially after reading some of the horror stories about providers like
Comcast.
That all ended when I woke up early one morning, noticed the internet
was down, and called their customer support number. As it turned out
the outage was neighborhood-wide, not just something at my house, and
they had it running again by the time I got to work that morning.
Beaurocracies being what they are, a trouble ticket was generated anyway
for my account, since I was the first one in the neighborhood to report
the problem. A few days later a technician comes by, work order in
hand, and replaces the 3COM with a RCA DCM315, as well as replacing the
cable drop outside the house.
Since then I've gone through 5 of the modems, and they've replaced the
cable drop yet again. About twice a day, on the average, the modem will
disconnect, and then go through the whole Tuning-Ranging-Registering
process, taking anywhere from 10 minutes to 3 hours to get back online.
It seems worse during daylight hours, but maybe that's just my
imagination.
I've got a few machines connected to it through a Linksys
BEFW11S4 router/switch, the same configuration that gave me no trouble
before the modem change. I never have problems reaching 192.168.100.1
(the modems IP on my side).
Here are the signal levels, etc. when it's working:
----------------------------------
Cable Signal Details
Forward Path: Return Path:
Signal Acquired at 603.000 MHz Connection: Acquired
SNR: 34.0 dB Frequency: 31.8 MHz
Received Signal Strength: 2.8 dBmV Power Level: 50.0 dBmV
Micro-Reflections: 41 dBc Channel ID: 4
Modulation: 256 QAM Modulation: QPSK
----------------------------------
And here's a typical cable modem event log:
----------------------------------
SYNC Timing Synchronization failure - Failed to acquire QAM/QPSK symbol
timing 00:00:02 - 01/01/1970 22:22:53 - 04/10/2004 6993
SYNC Timing Synchronization failure - Failed to acquire FEC framing
00:00:03 - 01/01/1970 22:22:53 - 04/10/2004 2330
No Ranging Response received - T3 time-out 00:00:06 - 01/01/1970
22:39:15 - 04/10/2004 2455
SYNC Timing Synchronization failure - Failed to receive MAC SYNC frame
within time-out period 00:00:08 - 01/01/1970 22:23:17 - 04/10/2004
594
Init RANGING Critical Ranging Request Retries exhausted 00:00:44 -
01/01/1970 22:39:06 - 04/10/2004 133
Started Unicast Maintenance Ranging - No Response received - T3 time-out
00:01:53 - 01/01/1970 22:41:54 - 04/10/2004 400
DHCP FAILED - Discover sent, no offer received 00:02:05 - 01/01/1970
00:03:46 - 01/01/1970 4
DHCP FAILED - Request sent, No response 00:02:32 - 01/01/1970 22:15:29
- 04/10/2004 4
DHCP WARNING - Non-critical field invalid in response. 00:02:33 -
01/01/1970 22:39:21 - 04/10/2004 9
Received Response to Broadcast Maintenance Request, But no Unicast
Maintenance opportunities received - T4 timeout 00:03:34 - 01/01/1970
22:37:30 - 04/10/2004 20
TLV-11 - Illegal Set operation failed 20:08:39 - 04/10/2004 22:39:24
- 04/10/2004 5
TFTP Failed - OUT OF ORDER packets 21:46:02 - 04/10/2004 21:46:02
- 04/10/2004 1
----------------------------------------
Many of the customer service people I've spoken to (at least those that
had any clue about how this stuff works) admit that these RCA modems
have been giving them trouble, but they're unable to do anything about
it because Corporate has decreed that only these will be used from now
on. (I'm guessing to make everything DOCSIS 2 compliant).
If I'm able to call them while it's down, they can detect that
something's amiss, but invariably when a technician finally arrives days
later everything's working fine, and all he has is a truck full of
DCM315's to swap out.
Harvey Gratt - 11 Apr 2004 04:08 GMT
> Just wondering if anyone else has had similar problems with these.
>
[quoted text clipped - 87 lines]
> later everything's working fine, and all he has is a truck full of
> DCM315's to swap out.
FWIW, I have Comcast in the Dallas, Texas area. I have a wireless home
network which uses a Belkin G router. I thought I had problems with the
router since it was losing internet connectivity every 20 minutes or so
with the original, Comcast supplied Motorola SB4200 modem.
In the end, the Motorola cable modem was the problem. I replaced it with
the RCA DCM315 and my setup has been trouble free for the last six months.
Based on my experience with Comcast and how they blame every problem on
someone else, I think your ISP is having problems independent of the
cable modem hardware.
Harvey
Heather - 21 Apr 2004 04:59 GMT
Motorola seems to be the best modem I worked tech support for AT&T @Home,
ATTBI & Comcast in my experiences on the phone Motorola turned out to be
the better modem in my opinion
> Just wondering if anyone else has had similar problems with these.
>
[quoted text clipped - 87 lines]
> later everything's working fine, and all he has is a truck full of
> DCM315's to swap out.
Anenga - 28 Apr 2004 22:32 GMT
> Just wondering if anyone else has had similar problems with these.
>
[quoted text clipped - 87 lines]
> later everything's working fine, and all he has is a truck full of
> DCM315's to swap out.
I have this SAME EXACT problem. The resets last between a few minutes
to the entire day. A month ago I replaced my RCA modem with a Motorola
SB5100. It has worked well for a few weeks, but now is doing the same
thing the RCA was doing. (Except not being so ultra-sensative that if
you touch the modem, it resets! -- which is what the RCA modem did)
I hesitate calling customer support too, because they end up coming
out and say "I don't see any problems" and then charge me. Last time
they said it was a neighbourhood problem, and I believe he changed the
cable ground as yours did.
Have you had any success? I too have a Wireless Linksys Router
(BEFW1154), though I've had these same problems with it not connected.
Do note there is a problem for Linksys G Series networking components,
as they are not compatable with certain non-Linksys modems. But I have
Series B, so that shouldn't be the problem.